Is Red-Dyed Hummingbird Nectar Safe for Your Hummingbirds? Not Likely!

Is Red-Dyed Hummingbird Nectar Safe?

You know the stuff… that bottled, cheap red liquid you see at Walmart, your local home improvement store, or even your grocery store. You may even see a neighbor giving it away on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or Nextdoor. But what’s the deal? Is it even usable? Is it safe for hummingbirds? Let’s dive in and find out - Is Red-dyed hummingbird nectar safe for your hummingbirds?

Several Ruby-throated Hummingbirds gather at a feeder before migrating south

The Best DIY Hummingbird Nectar Recipe

Before we break down the safety of red-dyed nectar, let’s talk about the best homemade hummingbird nectar recipe. It’s incredibly simple!

A juvenile ruby-throated hummingbird enjoys DIY nectar from a red-glass hummingbird feeder

The Best DIY Hummingbird Nectar Recipe

How to Make Safe Hummingbird Nectar:

1. Add 4 parts water to a small pot and bring to a boil.

2. Stir in 1 part plain white table sugar until fully dissolved.

3. Remove from heat and allow to cool to room temperature. (For faster cooling, refrigerate briefly.)

4. Thoroughly clean your hummingbird feeder before refilling with fresh nectar.

5. Hang your feeder back up and enjoy watching the hummingbirds!

This method is clean, safe, and quick. You don’t have to take our word for it—check out this resource from the Smithsonian National Zoo & Conservation Biology Institute: DIY Hummingbird Nectar Recipe

White table sugar mixed with boiling water is a much safer option when it comes to DIY Hummingbird food

A female Ruby-Throated Hummingbird perches for a drink

Is Store-Bought Red-Dyed Hummingbird Nectar Safe?

Examining Popular Brands

One of the most common store-bought nectar products is Perky-Pet Concentrated Hummingbird Nectar Sugar, which claims to be 100% sucrose. Since sucrose is metabolized efficiently by hummingbirds, this seems like a great option at first glance. However, there’s a major issue—it’s dyed red.

The Smithsonian and other experts recommend avoiding red dye in nectar. So why do companies like Perky-Pet continue using it? It’s likely a marketing tactic—humans are drawn to the red color, even though birds don’t need it in their nectar.

A silhouette of a Ruby-throated Hummingbird perched on a feeder

Why Red Dye is Bad for Hummingbirds?

Hummingbirds are naturally attracted to red flowers and feeders, but that doesn’t mean they need red-dyed nectar. Many experts, including hummingbird researcher Sheri L. Williamson, have publicly criticized the use of red dye in commercial nectar, noting its potential harm to birds. Despite concerns, some manufacturers continue producing red nectar without sufficient safety studies.

What are some safe alternatives to Red-Dyed Hummingbird Nectar

Instead of using commercial red-dyed nectar, opt for these safe alternatives:

• Homemade or DIY nectar (recipe included above)

• Clear, dye-free commercial nectar(product link here)

• Decorative Hummingbird Feeders with red accents instead of red nectar (We've included the top options below for durability and review rating!)

  • Billion Sky Lantern Style Hummingbird Feeder with Red Glass (product link here)

  
  

  

  Red glass lantern-style hummingbird feeder

  • Netvue Birdfy Smart Hummingbird Feeder with Solar Charging (product link here or click the image below)

    We recently reviewed the newer Netvue Birdfy Hum Feeder Duo camera as well, if you're interested in reading about the cool features and possibly shopping for one as well - give the blog a quick read!

    

    Netvue Birdfy Hummingbird Feeder with Solar Charging

A gorgeous adult male Ruby-throated Hummingbird perched at a feeder.

Our Final Thoughts about Premade or Red-dyed hummingbird nectar

So, is red-dyed hummingbird nectar safe? The answer is no. While some brands claim to be safe, red dye is unnecessary and likely harmful. Instead, opt for a simple homemade nectar recipe or a clear, dye-free alternative to keep your backyard hummingbirds healthy and happy.

Are you curious to learn more about hummingbird feeders, nectar, or other backyard birding tips? Let us know in the comments! Thanks for visiting and reading!

Is the Premade Clear hummingbird nectar safe for Hummingbirds?

Let's talk about this since more and more brands of store-bought nectar are emerging with clear hummingbird nectar products. What's more, they all claim to be safe for the birds. However, if you make your own following the simple recipe above in this blog, and you know that you need to change it every 3-4 days or more frequently than that based on the warm outdoor temps, how can a 'perfectly safe' nectar sit on the shelf for months at a time? Preservatives. Just like a twinkie that would last for years on a shelf - is that something you really want to feed to your feathered visitors?

I saw the clear nectar on sale at my local store. is it worth buying while on sale?

We did a quick cost-analysis for you. The average cost nationwide for a 4lb box of white table sugar is just a bit more than $3.00. With this one box of sugar you'll be able to mix 2.84 gallons of DIY nectar, and if you only fill your feeders 1/4 full (to reduce the amount of sugar water in your feeders also reduces the spoilage/mold growth!) you can expect to get around 91 refills for your feeders! 91! That's a cost of only $1.08 per gallon.

Now if you were to do that math for the leading clear nectars from Perky Pet, Pennington, Kaytee and others, they would be between $9.87 and $63.68 per gallon! So, when you combine the 10-60x more expensive nature of these products and the preservatives - we believe the case is very clear - to make your own hummingbird nectar, every time!

With that said - if you're still in the mood to buy some mix instead of the bottled premade solutions, we'll still share a couple of top options below for you:

1. BIRDBROS Nectar Powder - All natural, dye-free, no boiling necessary

2. Hummer's galore USA-made all natural, dye free, preservative free

- Birds of West Cobb (Lisa & Dan)